The Blog

Aug 27: Public Meeting

i Jul 12th No Comments by

The Living Islands Movement (LIM) has called a public meeting for Saturday, August 27 to put the case against building a super-incinerator at Shek Kwu Chau.

  • Date: Saturday 27 August 2011
  • Time: 3.30 pm
  • Venue: Squash Courts, 1/F Mui Wo Sports Centre (above the wet market)

Background: The Hong Kong Government proposes to build a super-incinerator at Shek Kwu Chau, preferring this site to the Tsang Tsui ash lagoons near Tuen Mun which were also assessed for this purpose.

The choice of Shek Kwu Chau (the island between South Lantau and Cheung Chau) is wrong because it:

  • Establishes a highly visible industrial undertaking in a pristine scenic landscape, rather than on an industrial brown field site
  • Will double the construction time to four years from two, despite the government’s argument the facility is urgently needed in order to preserve landfill capacity
  • Will cost about three times more than a similar facility in Tsang Tsui

LIM strongly urges you, your family and friends and neighbours to attend our public meeting to discuss:

  • The government’s reasons for choosing to build an incinerator so close to South Lantau
  • LIM’s arguments against the choice of Shek Kwu Chau
  • How you can get involved in fighting this ill-conceived proposal that will have a very negative impact on the South Lantau environment

The Situation to Date: :

The now temporarily withdrawn Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and the distorted conclusions drawn from it by the Environmental Protection Department (EPD) were a travesty in our view.

Furthermore, the Government is clearly trying to use incineration as the centrepiece of its so-called integrated waste management strategy while failing to address the root causes of the problem.

Therefore LIM is strongly urging the Government to scrap this plan and introduce a genuinely integrated waste reduction, recycling and management programme instead.

Click to view as a Google doc

The situation so far is:

  • The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) has been temporarily withdrawn because of technical irregularities
  • A draft Outline Zoning Plan for the scheme, plus a notice for the dredging and land reclamation have already been issued, and many of you sent objection letters before last week’s deadline
  • The flyer (above right) gives a brief summary of the proposal and our objections.

The EIA will surely be reissued in due course and LIM is already planning its response and to take other actions to ensure this ill-conceived plan does not go through. If you would like to find out more about this proposal and our suggested approach, please contact LIM at

We will need everybody’s support to win this so please pass this message on to anyone else who you feel would like to know more about the issue.

Best wishes,
Louise Preston, Chairperson, Living Islands Movement


Leave a reply